Recommended Reading on Historical Theory and Methodology
You may find the following books (all available in JCU's library) useful in furthering your understanding of historical methods and theory:
Joyce Appleby, Lynn Hunt, and Margaret Jacob, Telling the Truth About History.
Richard J. Evans, In Defense of History.
Mary Fullbrook, Historical Theory.
Martha Howell and Walter Prevenier, From Reliable Sources: An Introduction to Historical Methods.
Michel-Rolph Trouillot, Silencing the Past: Power and the Production of History.
Robert Chadwell Williams, The Historian's Toolbox.
COURSE SCHEDULE (N.B. The schedule and specific readings listed below may change.)--last updated October 16
PART ONE: Introductions
9/3. What is 'History' as a Practice?
9/5. Perspectives, methodologies, theories?
Appleby, Hunt, and Jacob, "Truth and Objectivity," in Telling the Truth About History, 241-270 (Shared Files, MyJCU)
Fulbrook, Historical Theory, 3-11, 27-30 (Shared Files, MyJCU)
9/10. Approaches and 'Types' of History
Arnold, History: A Very Short Introduction, Chapters 5-6 (Shared Files, MyJCU)
During this week, we will schedule individual meetings to start developing research topics.
9/12. A Brief Dive into Historiography (a.k.a. How has History as a Practice Changed?), Part I
Discussion of The American Historical Association's Guide to Historical Literature--First, Second, and Third Editions (See Shared Files, MyJCU for how to prepare--we'll also discuss this in class beforehand.)
9/17. A Brief Dive into Historiography (a.k.a. How has History as a Practice Changed?), Part II
Group Presentations on Major Historical Journal Contents, 1880s-2010s (See Shared Files, MyJCU for how to prepare--we'll also discuss this in class beforehand.)
PART TWO: Exploring the 'Conquest' of Mexico through a Revisionist Critique
9/19. The Story?: Early Paradigms and Revisionism
Restall, xiii-xix, 1-26 (Introduction, Ch. 1)
Prescott, The Conquest of Mexico (excerpts), required pp.401-405; recommended all of Book IV, Chapter III (Shared Files, MyJCU)
A Brief Dive into Historiography Reaction Paper Due
9/20. OFFICIAL JCU FRIDAY MAKE-UP--The King's Army?: History from Below, part I
Restall, 27-43 (Ch. 2)
9/24. Sources and Resources: Making the Most of the Library (We will Meet in the Library)
Guest Instructor: Manlio Perugini, Research Librarian
9/26. Sources and Resources, Part II: Preparing for the Primary Source Group Projects
Schwartz, "The Spanish Sources" and "The Indigenous Historical Traditions" (Shared Files, MyJCU)
Burkholder and Johnson, "The Conquest of Mexico" (Shared Files, MyJCU)
10/1. Spanish Conquistadors?: History from Below, part II
Restall, 44-63 (Ch. 3)
10/3. When Did It End?: Problems of Terminology and Periodization
Restall, 64-76 (Ch. 4)
10/8. Conquest through Communication?: Problems of Language, Part I
Todorov, The Conquest of America (excerpts) (Shared Files, MyJCU)
10/10. Who did the Speaking?: Problems of Language, Part II
Restall, 77-99 (Ch. 5)
Preliminary Bibliography and Paragraph Outlining Research Topic Due
10/15. Gods and Natives?: The Problems of Conversion
Review Restall, 77-99 (Ch. 5)
Restall, 100-130 (Ch. 6)
10/17. Superiority and 'Civilization'?: Narratives and Metanarratives
Restall, 131-157 (Ch. 7, Epilogue)
10/22. Primary Source Group Presentations
PART THREE: Exploring the 'Conquest'--Other Problems, Approaches, and Interpretations
Cultural Frontiers and Conversions: Ethnohistory and Gender Analysis
10/24. Ethnohistory and Gender Analysis: An Introduction
Irene Silverblatt, "Introduction" to Moon, Sun, and Witches: Gender Ideologies and Class in Inca and Colonial Peru (Shared Files, MyJCU)
Primary Source Paper Due
10/29. Gender and Conversion on the Frontier: Franciscans and Pueblos in New Mexico
Gutiérrez, "Franciscan Evangelization in New Mexico" (Shared Files, MyJCU)
10/31. The Workings and Meanings of Conversion in the Yucatan
Farriss, "The Cosmic Order in Crisis" (Shared Files, MyJCU)
11/5. Gender, Conversion and 'Resistance': 'Witchcraft' in the Andes
Silverblatt, "Cultural Defiance: The Sorcery Weapon" (Shared Files, MyJCU)
The Material World: Environmental History and Material Culture
11/7. Ecological Imperialism?: Making Use of the Sciences
Miller, "Nature's Conquests" (Shared Files, MyJCU)
11/12. Through the Lens of Material Culture
Bauer, Goods, Power, History (excerpts) (Shared Files, MyJCU)
PART FOUR: YOUR RESEARCH--Research Paper Drafts Due One Week Before you are Presenting
11/14. Presentation/Discussion of Research Papers
11/19. Presentation/Discussion of Research Papers
11/21. Presentation/Discussion of Research Papers
11/26. Presentaiton/Discussion of Research Papers
PART FIVE: Public History, Memory and Meanings
12/3. Commemorating the Conquest?
Michel-Rolph Trouillot, "Good Day, Columbus" from Silencing the Past: Power and the Production of History (Shared Files, MyJCU)
12/5. Conclusions
Final Draft of Research Paper Due (When you hand in your final draft of your research paper, you should also hand in the earlier draft with my comments as well.)
|